Pryor Mountain mustangs: More than numbers on a page

By: 
John Bernhisel

Pryor Mountain Wild Mustang Center director explains concerns over BLM plan to reduce historic herd

It does not take long sitting across the table from Nancy Cerroni to realize that, for her, the debate over the future of the Pryor Mountain wild horses is about much more than numbers. There are plenty of numbers, of course. Appropriate Management Levels, population projections, genetic diversity calculations, age ratios and removal targets fill hundreds of pages of federal documents.

But Cerroni, director of the Pryor Mountain Wild Mustang Center in Lovell, also knows the horses. She knows their mothers. She knows their offspring. She knows which family lines have been on the mountain for generations. She can describe the characteristics that hint at the herd’s historic Spanish ancestry. And behind her are decades of records documenting individual horses, records that began before she ever became involved.

That is why she is troubled by the Bureau of Land Management’s new plan for managing the herd. It is not that Cerroni believes no horses should ever be removed. In fact, she said she is comfortable with the BLM’s initial goal of reducing the herd to about 150 animals. It is which horses are removed, and what happens after that, that worries her.

According to BLM documents, the agency’s spring census counted 187 horses at least a year old, including 82 studs and 105 mares. The long-term plan establishes an Appropriate Management Level, or AML, of 107 to 120 horses. The initial gather would reduce the herd to approximately 150, with subsequent gathers eventually moving toward the lower end of the AML.

Cerroni believes 150 is a much better number, noting, “Personally, I think 150 is a great number for the herd.”

She points to previous recommendations from equine geneticist Gus Cothran, BLM guidance concerning genetic viability and the history of the Pryor herd itself.

“The average size of this herd in the past 50 years has been 150,” she said.

 

A long relationship with the BLM

One thing Cerroni wants people to understand is that the Mustang Center has traditionally worked very well with the BLM. The relationship has not always been difficult. Quite the opposite.

“We have never filed a lawsuit, nor do we intend to on this one,” Cerroni said. “There was always a strong collaboration between the BLM and the Mustang Center. We really strongly believe you can work together with someone, rather than on the outside. And unfortunately, we don’t have that relationship right now.”

Cerroni hopes that can change, noting, “I’m hoping that can change in time.”

The Mustang Center has, however, appealed the BLM’s management decisions through the Interior Board of Land Appeals. Cerroni views that differently from a lawsuit because an administrative appeal is part of the process provided by the BLM itself. The BLM plan confirms that decisions may be appealed to the IBLA and that a petition for a stay may also be filed.

 

Which horses leave?

Perhaps the biggest disagreement comes down to one simple question: If horses must come off the mountain, which ones should leave?

The BLM considered four management alternatives. The selected plan uses primarily age- and sex-based removal criteria. A lineage-based alternative was considered but rejected in part because DNA testing confirmed paternity information in only 72.5 percent of cases.

Under the selected criteria, horses with certain genetic defects or close inbreeding are considered first. After that, horses are removed to reach desired age and sex ratios, with preference given to animals ages 1 to 4, followed by those ages 5 to 10. Horses 20 and older are not to be removed during planned gathers. Color is considered last.

That is where Cerroni believes something important is being missed. The BLM’s own management objective, she noted, calls for maintaining characteristics typical of Pryor Mountain horses of mixed ancestry, including Colonial Spanish ancestry.

“They’re saying right there, we want to maintain these characteristics of these horses that are really unique,” Cerroni said. “But the problem with their selective removal criteria ... is there’s no way for them to do that.”

To Cerroni, the answer is not simply testing every horse and keeping the ones that are “most Spanish.” It is far more complicated. It means looking at generations of information. “You look at horses and say, how well represented is that lineage?” she said. “We start with the maternity, and then if we have to, we go to the paternity.”

The BLM counters that removing an individual does not necessarily eliminate a bloodline because its genetic material may remain in siblings, cousins and other relatives throughout the herd.

Cerroni believes the remarkable amount of information available on this particular herd should allow managers to make more informed choices.

“This herd has the best documentation,” she said.

Those records date to the late 1960s and early 1970s, when the Mustang Center’s founder, the Rev. Floyd Schwieger, began recording information about individual horses.

“I have his notebooks full, literally spiral-bound notebooks full of information about individual horses,” Cerroni said. Her son, Matthew Dillon, eventually transferred that information into a database, and the Center has continued building upon it.

“That’s the kind of information we have, and this is the kind of information that is not being included in their plan,” she said. “And that’s sad.”

Cerroni’s criticism is particularly pointed because she believes the BLM has previously recognized the unusual opportunity presented by such extensive records.

“They are not doing the due diligence,” she said, to ensure that the characteristics of the historic Pryor horses are maintained. “That’s the biggie.”

 

A range under stress

The BLM, however, argues that doing nothing carries serious risks of its own. In 2021, a Rangeland Health Assessment found the range failed to meet three land-health standards. The agency cites changes in plant communities, bare ground and erosion, overuse around Cottonwood Spring and damage to habitat for the Pryor Mountains bladderpod, a sensitive plant found only in the area. The agency identifies wild horse overpopulation as the causal factor in all three cases.

Without removals, BLM modeling also projects the herd could reach approximately 291 horses within 10 years. The agency warns that under that scenario, “the range’s ability to support healthy horses could collapse,” potentially resulting in an emergency gather or widespread mortality.

Cerroni calls the 291-horse projection “speculation,” but she does not argue that the herd should simply be allowed to grow without management. Her disagreement is over how that management should be accomplished and how far the herd should ultimately be reduced.

 

A unique Spanish heritage

Then the conversation turns away from government assessments and environmental concerns. Ask Cerroni what makes a Pryor Mountain horse special, and her language changes.

The horses showing their old Spanish characteristics, she explained, tend to be compact and sturdy.

“They’re very short-backed, they’re very short-statured, they’re just small, chubby, chunky,” she said, smiling at her own description. “I call them concrete blocks on four legs.”

Then she describes their faces.

“They’re really beautiful-faced,” she said, describing their wide-set eyes and faces tapering toward the muzzle. And then there are the ears. “Their little ears are super cute because they’re curved and tipped in black.”

That may explain the issue better than any federal report can. For Cerroni, these aren’t 187 interchangeable horses that need to become 150, then 120 and eventually perhaps 107. They are generations of animals she and others have watched, photographed, documented and, in many cases, known since birth.

The BLM says its genetic modeling indicates the herd can maintain sufficient genetic diversity under the new management plan. Cerroni’s concern is different. She worries about what could disappear along the way if managers concentrate on overall genetic diversity without paying enough attention to individual family lines and the historic characteristics that make the Pryor herd unique.

And there is something else she doesn’t want lost. While discussing the prospect of removing younger animals and using fertility control, Cerroni worried that the result could eventually be an older herd with fewer foals. For all the pages of management plans and population projections, she summed up what could be lost much more simply. Then she smiled. “That’s the fun of it, to see the babies.”

Finally, when asked what the local community could do to help support the Pryor Mountain horses and the Mustang Center, Cerroni said one of the most important things is simply to become informed about the horses and what is happening on the range.

“I think just the community being knowledgeable and being able to speak on behalf of the horses,” she said. “Being informed.” She also encouraged residents to recognize the value the horses bring to the entire area, particularly through tourism. “They really are a huge tourist draw,” she said.

Cerroni would also like more local residents to stop at the Pryor Mountain Wild Mustang Center and learn about the herd for themselves.

“Please come visit,” she said. “We don’t get a lot of local visitors at the Mustang Center.” She recalled recently being on the mountain with a visitor who told her, “I wouldn’t be here. I wouldn’t come to Lovell if it wasn’t for those horses.”

Category: